Climate Conversation Group

Taking the heat out of global warming

For the first time in history, people shouting “the end is nigh” are somehow
the sane ones, while those of us who say it is not are now the lunatics.

  • rss
  • Home
  • Open threads
    • Climate – how to use open threads
      • Meteorology
      • Global warming
      • Climate science
        • Climate Models
        • Papers
        • Atmosphere
        • Temperature records
        • Energy and fuel
        • Solar
        • Ocean heat content
        • Radiation, radiative imbalance
        • Sea levels
        • Ocean acidification
        • Polar regions, glaciers and ice
      • Regions
        • Europe
        • Asia
        • South America
        • Africa
        • Australia
        • UK
        • USA
        • Pacific
        • New Zealand
      • News
      • Controversy and scandal
        • Skeptical Science
      • Disproving AGW
      • Economics
    • Politics
      • ETS and carbon taxes
    • UN
      • IPCC organisation
      • IPCC politics
      • IPCC science
      • NIPCC
  • Opinion polls
    • SckSckSck
    • Your view of CO2
    • Collective noun for icebergs
    • Stop the ETS
  • Climate of Freedom Tour
  • Files
    • Climate Realists
      • Newsletter #17 6 May 2010
      • Newsletter #16 28 Apr 2010
      • Newsletter #6 11 Feb 2010
      • Newsletter #4 2011
    • News releases
      • February 8, 2010
      • December 20, 2010
    • Wind turbine failures
  • About

King says Maoris have always owned water

Richard Treadgold | September 13, 2012

His people believe him

Well of course they do.

via Maori have always owned water – 3 News.

Earlier today King Tuheitia told the national hui on the issue that Maori have always owned water.

The big chiefs and the long-time activists were at Turangawaewae to discuss one issue – water – and looking for one thing – unity.

So, King Tuheitia told the hui “we’ve always owned the water”; you’re quite sure that the hui didn’t tell him? Because I was under the firm impression that the purpose of a hui was to find the will of the people, not to announce it to them.

Just one question: why do Maoris say they own the water, when no other race on Earth believes that they do?

Do they know what water is?

water

Water is very large. There is so much of it that you cannot even hold it all in your possession, so you cannot defend it. We all know you did not create it, because all of it was here before you were born. Every atom of it will be here after you die, so we’ll get it all back then anyway, however you manage to bully us over it while you’re here. We’d prefer you went home and stopped making a noise about it. Earn your money as we all do – by hard work, intelligence and perseverance. That will make you happy. But keep your hands off our water.

Categories
General
Tags
Maori, New Zealand, Water, Water rights
Comments rss
Comments rss
Trackback
Trackback

« The unstoppable MWP Seeing freedom and truth as disease »

14 Responses to “King says Maoris have always owned water”

  1. Andy says:
    September 13, 2012 at 9:15 pm

    They also claim to own the wind. I guess the Sun is next

    Reply
  2. Richard C (NZ) says:
    September 13, 2012 at 9:51 pm

    They own the water (and presumably are responsible for it) which by extension is the hydrological cycle.

    Therefore they can be sued for droughts and floods (extreme weather), heavy snowfall, no snowfall, hail damage, tsunamis, king tides etc.

    Careful what you wish for.

    Reply
  3. Gary Kerkin says:
    September 14, 2012 at 8:26 am

    I would have thought that prior to the introduction of agriculture which required irrigation, reticulated town water supply, and hydroelectricity generation water had no value.

    Reply
  4. Richard C (NZ) says:
    September 14, 2012 at 12:15 pm

    Psalm 65:9
    Thou visitest the earth, and waterest it: thou greatly enrichest it with the river of God, which is full of water: thou preparest them corn, when thou hast so provided for it.

    Maori culture gazumps Christian culture it seems.

    Reply
    • Richard C (NZ) says:
      September 14, 2012 at 12:24 pm

      Revelation 21:6
      And he said unto me, It is done. I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end. I will give unto him that is athirst of the fountain of the water of life freely.

      Spiritual analogy of course, but there is an implication……

      Reply
      • Richard C (NZ) says:
        September 14, 2012 at 12:38 pm

        “Spiritual analogy of course” – Apparently not, just other-realmish.

        Revelation 22:1
        And he shewed me a pure river of water of life, clear as crystal, proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb.

        I wonder if Maori own that water too.

        Reply
  5. David says:
    September 14, 2012 at 12:20 pm

    I’m stunned. I really am. Someone actually watches TV 3!

    Reply
  6. Robin Pittwood says:
    September 14, 2012 at 12:31 pm

    And the TV arrives by electromagnetic waves. I think they own the radio spectrum too, don’t they.

    Reply
    • Andy says:
      September 14, 2012 at 12:44 pm

      and internet domains – .maori.nz

      We are spiritually connected to our domain names (well I am anyway as mine is my own name)

      Reply
      • Andy says:
        September 14, 2012 at 1:27 pm

        It’s possible to register internet domains maori.nz with macron characters now.

        So now you can be politically correct and have a domain name with macrons, but no one will visit your site because they can’t find the macrons on their keyboard

        Reply
  7. Richard C (NZ) says:
    September 14, 2012 at 1:11 pm

    Owning water is one thing but the energy of it is another thing entirely.

    Hydro energy occurs by virtue of mass, gravity and height but only if the structures are put in place to first of all create the height (a dam, that was never there pre-European) then the penstocks, turbines and generators (they were never there pre-European either).

    That is, potential energy was created by the dam builders (NZ taxpayer for public works, not Maori) then kinetic energy harnessed by the generation structure builders (again NZ taxpayers for public works, not Maori).

    Without a dam the only energy to be harnessed is run-of-river by immersion of tidal-type micro turbines but that energy is still by virtue of natural height that was in place pre-Maori and a result of tectonic upheaval over a geologic timeframe far longer than Maori discovery and habitation.

    The same can be said for public water reservoirs and non-bore irrigation systems.

    And further to my earlier comment, Maori have a problem claiming ownership of river water when that water is transient, it circulates via the hydrological cycle of which Maori have no control over in terms of scope (ocean. atmosphere, land) or rate (river flow volume, snows, ocean evaporation, precipitation etc).

    I think they are biting off more than they can chew.

    Reply
  8. Richard C (NZ) says:
    September 14, 2012 at 2:06 pm

    Did the Waikato River exist prior to the Taupo eruption and subsequent lake formation?

    If not (I don’t think it did), Maori are claiming ownership (in the case of the Waikato River) of something that evolved geologically (i.e. naturally) by volcanism. The origin of the river therefore is volcanism, are Maori claiming ownership of that too?

    Volcanism of New Zealand
    From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    The volcanism of New Zealand has been responsible for many of the country’s geographical features, especially in the North Island and the country’s outlying islands. It has also claimed many lives.

    While the land’s volcanic history dates back to before the Zealandia microcontinent rifted away from Gondwana 60-130 million years ago, activity continues today with minor eruptions occurring every few years. This recent activity is primarily due to the country’s position on the boundary between the Indo-Australian and Pacific Plates, a part of the Pacific Ring of Fire, and particularly the subduction of the Pacific Plate under the Indo-Australian Plate.

    New Zealand’s rocks record examples of almost every kind of volcanism observed on Earth, including some of the world’s largest eruptions in geologically recent times.

    Reply
  9. Stanley says:
    September 15, 2012 at 6:24 pm

    Aren’t human bodies 90% water? If so, does this mean that maori people are mainly owned by other maori people?

    It will be interesting if the Ngapuhi Iwi claim that they own 90% of Tainui, or vice-versa.

    What about the rain? Does the king own in on the way down or only when it lands?

    If all of us taxpayers buy the ownership from the Maori, how are we going to divvy it up? Percentages? Litres? Come to think of it, how do they divvy it up?

    Reply
  10. Andrew W says:
    September 18, 2012 at 6:09 pm

    Wonder how long till they claim ownership of rainfall and start charging farmers for it, and come to think of it, surely they also own the sunlight that falls on Aotearoa.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.

buy FastProof now

          • Climate Conversation Group •
   • more than 1,400,000 visits a year
   • over 7,600,000 hits a year
               — join the Conversation —

Hot off the press

  • Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Emotional knowledge
  • Global warming less than we thought
  • Climate porkies from TV One
  • Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Renowden a scaring warmist
  • Hide sticks it to Renwick
  • The incredibly elusive absolute surface air temperature
  • Faults, fallacies and failures of wind power
  • For real striving, give up the driving
  • Cost to ‘restore climate’ a game-changer
  • Signs of strain in justifying climate predictions
  • Is the game nearly over
  • IPCC created and controlled by activists
  • Policy: politicians write it but scientists incite it
  • The industry of denial
  • Lord Monckton complains to VUW
  • Climate forecasts fulfilled or what?
  • Snip-it
  • Forget prosperity, we need the extra tree

Latest comments

  • Richard C (NZ) on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Andy on Global warming less than we thought
  • Andy on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Richard C (NZ) on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Richard C (NZ) on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Andy on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Richard C (NZ) on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Richard C (NZ) on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • David on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Richard C (NZ) on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Mike Jowsey on Emotional knowledge
  • Richard C (NZ) on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Mike Jowsey on Emotional knowledge
  • Mike Jowsey on Emotional knowledge
  • Andy on Global warming less than we thought
  • Andy on Global warming less than we thought
  • Bob D on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Richard C (NZ) on Painting wanting rebuttal
  • Andy on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought
  • Richard Treadgold on Renwick doesn’t blame AGW for drought

PayPal Tip Jar
Even a couple of dollars helps us
(if you're in the mood). Thanks!


Click to get your own widget

Tags

Activists AGW Air temperature Air temperature Alarmists Alternative energy Australia Carbon dioxide Carbon Sense Carbon trading CCG blog Christopher Monckton Climate Conversation Group Climate research Climate Science Court action Data quality Disproving AGW Economics Energy supply Environmentalism ETS General Global temperature Global warming Hot Topic IPCC Journalism New Zealand NIWA NIWAgate NZCSC NZ Herald NZ temperature records Oceans Politics Royal Society Sceptics Science bias Scientists Sea levels United Nations USA Watts Up With That What is the evidence

Admin

  • Log in
  • Entries RSS
  • Comments RSS
  • WordPress.org

Climate change links

  • Bishop Hill
  • Carbon Sense Coalition
  • Climate Audit—a science blog
  • Climate Debate Daily
  • Climate Depot
  • Climate Etc. (Judith Curry)
  • Climate Realists
  • Global warming at a glance
  • Jo Nova
  • Kiwi Thinker
  • NZ Climate Science Coalition
  • Science of Doom
  • Watts Up With That

 

September 2012
M T W T F S S
« Aug   Oct »
 12
3456789
10111213141516
17181920212223
24252627282930

Previous posts

Oil prices

models v. reality
Latest climate models v. reality

As the models continue to leave actual temperature readings in their dust, sizeable warming halted about 1995 — although it might resume at any time. It must hasten to have any hope of catching up with the predictions.

If you claim warming continues, we want evidence of continued warming — eminently reasonable. Making us wait for 17 years for that evidence invites us to doubt you.

Claiming that warming hasn't stopped is the same as claiming it has — and both are ridiculous, for nobody knows the future. The best you can do is describe the past.

Click graph for larger version.

 

rss Comments rss valid xhtml 1.1 design by jide powered by Wordpress get firefox